The Pizza Restaurant in Windermere That Locals Make Their Own
Residents of Windermere know what they want from a local restaurant: quality food, a menu wide enough for the whole table, and hours that work for a Wednesday night and a Saturday noon. Pie-fection Pizza at 13211 Reams Rd Suite 108 checks all of those — with the added dimension of a Brazilian-Italian menu that lifts the Windermere pizza restaurant category into its own lane. Three Central Florida locations (Windermere, Orlando Metrowest, and Kissimmee) share the same menu and the same approach: authentic Brazilian flavors, Italian technique, and a kitchen that takes the full dining experience seriously from starter to dessert.
A Pizza Restaurant in Windermere with a Brazilian Pantry
Catupiry — the creamy Brazilian cheese spread that anchors Pie-fection’s specialty pizzas — is the ingredient that most regulars cite when describing what makes the restaurant different. It shows up in the Chicken Catupiry, Shrimp Catupiry, and Corn Catupiry, each one with its own balance of richness and flavor. But the pizza menu covers considerably more ground than catupiry alone. The Supreme, House Special, Diplomat, and Italian pizzas give the classic side of the menu genuine variety — options that reward guests who come back often. The Greek and Portuguese pizzas draw from Mediterranean tradition. The Margherita ($19 small / $33 large) and Mozzarella ($14 / $28) anchor the menu for anyone who prefers something clean and familiar.
Among the Brazilian originals, the Paraíba — jerked beef (carne seca) paired with caramelized banana — is the pizza that earns the most surprised return visits. The Strogonoff (steak stroganoff and potato sticks on a fermented crust) shows how Brazilian cooking translates into pizza without losing its character. The complete selection is at the Pie-fection Pizza Menu.
Pasta, Parmigiana, and What Makes This More Than a Pizza Spot
The pasta section is the part of Pie-fection’s menu that tends to catch guests off guard — in the best way. Fettuccine Alfredo ($16) and Spaghetti with Mushroom Sauce ($20) anchor the everyday end of the pasta list, while Chicken Parmigiana ($24) and Filet Parmigiana ($32) demonstrate the same Italian-Brazilian craft that runs through the rest of the kitchen. Fettuccine Filet Mignon Bites ($23) is the combination that brings the grill and the pasta station together in a single dish.
At the premium end, Crema Di Padano ($38) is the standout — fettuccine finished tableside inside a Grana Padano cheese wheel, available at all three locations including Windermere. It’s the kind of dish that signals this is a full-service restaurant built around serious cooking, not just an exceptional pizza shop. For a table that includes guests with different appetites — some who want pizza, others who want pasta, others who want something in between — Pie-fection handles all of them without compromise.
Weekly Deals, Sweet Pizzas, and Pizza Party Catering in Windermere
For events and group dining, Pie-fection’s Pizza Party service brings the restaurant to any Windermere venue — a mobile oven, fresh on-site preparation, savory pizzas for the first two hours and sweet ones to close. The Starter Package covers up to 30 guests for three hours at $1,050, with a $300 deposit to secure the date and additional guests at $35 per person. It fits neighborhood birthday parties, HOA community events, and corporate team gatherings equally well.
Monday through Thursday at any location, ordering two large pizzas earns a free small sweet Brazilian pizza with promo code SWEETFREE. The sweet pizza selection is part of what sets Pie-fection apart as a pizza restaurant in Windermere: Brigadeiro (Brazil’s most beloved chocolate bonbon in pizza form), Romeo and Juliet (guava and cheese, a classic Brazilian pairing), and Churros Pizza (dulce de leche and cinnamon) are the standouts among the eight options on the menu. To reserve your table for the week or the weekend, book through Reservation – Windermere on OpenTable.
Your Pizza Restaurant in Windermere — Reserve or Order Online
The Windermere location is at 13211 Reams Rd Suite 108, Windermere, FL 34786, open Monday through Thursday 5:00 PM–11:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from noon to midnight, and Sunday from noon to 11:00 PM. Call (407) 720-4001 and place your order in advance at Online Ordering – Windermere.
The Orlando (Metrowest) location is at 3120 S Kirkman Rd, Orlando, FL 32811, open Tuesday through Thursday 5:00 PM–11:00 PM, Friday–Saturday 4:00 PM–12:00 AM, Sunday 5:00 PM–11:00 PM (closed Mondays). Call (407) 523-2200, book via Reservation – Orlando, or order at Online Ordering – Orlando.
Kissimmee is at 720 Centerview Blvd, Kissimmee, FL 34741, open Monday through Thursday 4:00 PM–11:00 PM, Friday–Saturday 4:00 PM–12:00 AM, Sunday 5:00 PM–11:00 PM. Call (407) 603-0123, book through Reservation – Kissimmee, or go to Online Ordering – Kissimmee.
A pizza restaurant in Windermere that earns a regular spot on the calendar is one that holds up on a busy Tuesday and delivers on a slow Saturday lunch. From the catupiry pies and the pasta selection to the Brigadeiro sweet pizza and the tableside Crema Di Padano, Pie-fection at 13211 Reams Rd Suite 108 is the local answer that works for every version of that evening out.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes Pie-fection Pizza a good pizza restaurant in Windermere for the whole family?
Pie-fection Pizza covers a wide range of the table. The kids menu runs $10–$15 with options including Cheese Pizza, Chicken Tenders, Pepperoni Pizza, Fettuccine Alfredo, and Filet Mignon with Rice & Fries. Adults have access to the full menu — catupiry specialty pizzas, pasta, Signature Specials, grills, and chef-driven entrées. The Windermere location opens at noon on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays, making it a practical choice for weekend family lunches as well as evening dinners. Call (407) 720-4001 or reserve at Reservation – Windermere.
Does Pie-fection Pizza Windermere serve pasta dishes?
Yes. The pasta menu at Pie-fection includes Fettuccine Alfredo ($16), Spaghetti with Mushroom Sauce ($20), Chicken Parmigiana ($24), Filet Parmigiana ($32), Fettuccine Filet Mignon Bites ($23), and the tableside Crema Di Padano — fettuccine finished inside a Grana Padano cheese wheel ($38). Pasta is available at all three Pie-fection locations including Windermere.
Are there weekday deals at Pie-fection Pizza Windermere?
Yes. Monday through Thursday, order two large pizzas at any Pie-fection location and receive a free small sweet Brazilian pizza — use promo code SWEETFREE at checkout. Additionally, online orders of $50 or more at any location qualify for 10% off with promo code pie10. Call (407) 720-4001 or order online at Online Ordering – Windermere.
Can Pie-fection Pizza cater an event in the Windermere area?
Yes. The Pizza Party package brings a mobile oven and fresh on-site pizza preparation to any venue in or around Windermere. The Starter Package covers up to 30 guests for three hours at $1,050, with a $300 deposit to reserve the date. Additional guests are $35 per person. Children’s pricing applies for ages 4–11. Contact Pie-fection at (407) 720-4001 or submit an inquiry at Pizza Party on the website.