The Pizza Restaurant in Orlando That Goes Beyond the Pie
There’s a difference between a pizza place and a pizza restaurant — and in Orlando, Pie-fection Pizza sits firmly in the second category. Founded by José Emanuel (“Maninho”) and his family after relocating to Florida in 2011, the restaurant was built as a complete dining destination: Brazilian culinary heritage and Italian pizza craft joined by a kitchen that runs from catupiry pies to chef-driven risottos, premium grills, and handcrafted desserts. The flagship Orlando location at Metrowest anchors the concept, with supporting locations in Kissimmee and Windermere. For anyone searching for a pizza restaurant in Orlando that earns a return visit, this is the one to start with.
The Pizza That Defines a Pizza Restaurant in Orlando
Catupiry — a Brazilian creamy cheese spread with richness that mozzarella can’t replicate on its own — is the ingredient that marks Pie-fection’s identity. The Shrimp Catupiry ($24 small / $39 large) is among the most ordered, pairing the sweetness of shrimp against catupiry’s depth in a combination that reads as distinctly Brazilian. The Chicken Catupiry ($23 / $38), Corn Catupiry ($24 / $39), and Canadian Ham Catupiry ($24 / $39) each build on that same base with their own character.
The menu extends into territory that most pizza restaurants in Orlando don’t explore. The Portuguese pizza draws from Mediterranean tradition. The Paraíba — jerked beef (carne seca) with caramelized banana — comes from Brazilian home cooking and lands better than it sounds on first read. The Strogonoff (steak stroganoff, potato sticks on a fermented crust) demonstrates how Brazilian flavors translate without losing anything in the process. The complete range is at the Pie-fection Pizza Menu.
Beyond Pizza: The Full Restaurant Menu at Pie-fection Orlando
What separates Pie-fection from a standard pizza restaurant in Orlando is what the kitchen produces beyond the pizza oven. The risotto program alone is reason enough to reserve a table: Shrimp Risotto ($28), Risotto Al Funghi with Filet ($42), Malbec Risotto with Lamb Chops ($42), and Gorgonzola Risotto with NY Strip ($44) are each built to anchor a full dinner, not simply fill space on a menu. Salmon with Vegetables ($32) and Filet Mignon au Poivre ($47) round out the entrée range for guests who want something beyond the pie.
On the grill, Sliced Picanha with Fried Yuca ($23) — one of Brazil’s most celebrated cuts — brings the same Brazilian identity that runs through the pizza menu into a shared-plate format. Book the Orlando table through Reservation – Orlando on OpenTable, or place an order in advance at Online Ordering – Orlando.
Group Dining, Events, and What Else Pie-fection Brings to Orlando
For groups and events, the Pizza Party package turns the Pie-fection experience portable — a mobile oven, fresh on-site preparation, savory pizzas for the first two hours and sweet ones to close. The Starter Package begins at $1,050 for up to 30 guests over three hours, with a $300 deposit to lock in the date and additional guests at $35 per person. It works equally well for birthdays, corporate gatherings, and neighborhood celebrations.
At the Metrowest Orlando restaurant, All You Can Eat runs Tuesday through Thursday, 5:00 PM to 11:00 PM — 23 gourmet pizza flavors at $25 per adult (minimum two people, dine-in only) — giving regulars a recurring reason to treat Pie-fection as their standing pizza restaurant in Orlando. The brand also extends to the Pie Pie Pizza Challenge, a mobile game for iOS and Android that puts players in the kitchen alongside Chef Manny — managing recipes, serving guests, and completing delivery missions — bringing the restaurant’s character into game form.
Reserve Your Table — Orlando, Kissimmee, and Windermere
The Metrowest Orlando flagship is at 3120 S Kirkman Rd, Orlando, FL 32811, open Tuesday through Thursday 5:00 PM–11:00 PM, Friday–Saturday 4:00 PM–12:00 AM, Sunday 5:00 PM–11:00 PM (closed Mondays). Call (407) 523-2200.
The Kissimmee location is at 720 Centerview Blvd, Kissimmee, FL 34741, open Monday through Thursday 4:00 PM–11:00 PM, Friday–Saturday 4:00 PM–12:00 AM, Sunday 5:00 PM–11:00 PM. Call (407) 603-0123, book via Reservation – Kissimmee, or order at Online Ordering – Kissimmee.
Windermere is at 13211 Reams Rd Suite 108, Windermere, FL 34786, open Monday through Thursday 5:00 PM–11:00 PM and from noon on weekends. Call (407) 720-4001, reserve via Reservation – Windermere, or go to Online Ordering – Windermere.
A pizza restaurant in Orlando earns that description when the kitchen behind the pizza is as strong as the pizza itself. From the catupiry pies and Shrimp Risotto to the Sliced Picanha and the Malbec with Lamb Chops, Pie-fection delivers a full restaurant in every sense of the word — across three Central Florida locations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Pie-fection Pizza a good restaurant for a date night or special occasion in Orlando?
Yes. The Orlando (Metrowest) location offers a full-service dinner menu that includes Signature Specials on a slow-fermented crust (Burrata, Branco, Amore — $31–$32), risottos including the Malbec Risotto with Lamb Chops ($42) and Gorgonzola Risotto with NY Strip ($44), and Filet Mignon au Poivre ($47). Reservations are recommended for evenings and weekends — book through Reservation – Orlando or call (407) 523-2200.
Does Pie-fection Pizza serve more than just pizza in Orlando?
Yes. The menu includes Chef’s Suggestions such as Shrimp Risotto ($28), Risotto Al Funghi with Filet ($42), Salmon with Vegetables ($32), and Filet Mignon au Poivre ($47). The grill section features Sliced Picanha with Fried Yuca ($23–$34). Appetizers, salads, pastas, and a full dessert menu round out what is a complete full-service restaurant, not simply a pizza spot.
Which Pie-fection Pizza location is closest to downtown Orlando?
The Metrowest location at 3120 S Kirkman Rd, Orlando, FL 32811 is the Orlando flagship and the closest to the greater Orlando metro area. It is open Tuesday through Thursday 5:00 PM–11:00 PM, Friday–Saturday 4:00 PM–12:00 AM, and Sunday 5:00 PM–11:00 PM (closed Mondays). Call (407) 523-2200 or order online at Online Ordering – Orlando.
What is the Pie Pie Pizza Challenge at Pie-fection Pizza?
The Pie Pie Pizza Challenge is a mobile game by Pie-fection Pizza, available on iOS and Android. Players step into the kitchen alongside Chef Manny — following pizza recipes, managing customer service in the dining room, and completing delivery missions against the clock. It’s a game that reflects the restaurant’s personality and brand, available as a free download on both major app stores.